During Pastor Hoffmeister's service, a brick church was built in 1867, with the dedication of the new Salem Lutheran Church being held on Christmas that year.
Following are the pastors who served Salem Lutheran Church during the years indicated:
|Karl Hoffmeister||1856-1857, 1864-1868||(See above)|
|J. J. Waldburger||1868-1870|
|Henry E. Hoff||1889-1922|
|Alfred Hoff (Henry Hoff's son)||1923-1933|